Which of the bunch. have the best repu for this particular lens please guys?

i have the sigma 12-24 which is very wide on my full frame - for sharpness and obviously distortion it's not great - but for the money it's certainly not too bad... for that width you'll struggle to get anything decent for under £1,000 and they still won't be much better.
I've had magazine covers from mine!!

Thanks Paul.............WoW! Mag covers"""

Yes, quite like what I have seen of it so far, liked the feel of the lens also.MPO didn't think sharpness was too bad. Think I will ponder and try others first, before deciding. Just purchased the 28-105mm zoom, I like this lens a lot I have to say.

Getting a little collection now:) about 8

mate of mine has one, says it's soft on the edges other than that fine and half the price of the Nikon version.

It's on my want list.

£60 on ebay wasn't bad in and in perfect condtiton!

what - i can't find them less than 340 quid.

Yep bargain?:)